I think petco just modified their recipe for their WholeHearted line, no gums or carrageenan. The tops from the label are white. MarcyMM mentioned: My Buddy is currently eighteen and his blood checks present ALL ordinary levels - everyhing! The vet states he's in surprisingly fantastic wellbeing for his age. https://johnathantepzj.techionblog.com/35715601/top-dog-food-secrets